4 Makeup Artists and Beauty Editors Walk Into Sephora—the 13 Mascaras They Buy

Let’s be honest; shopping at a monster retailer like Sephora can feel overwhelming. Whether you’re there shopping for the best foundation, concealer, or other product, there are so many options it can be hard to narrow down which ones will work for you. While help from a Sephora employee is always welcomed and appreciated, we also don’t mind taking matters into our own hands here at Who What Wear. If you’re shopping for the best mascara at Sephora, let us save you some trouble. I’ve rounded up a list of the top 13 mascaras that both editors and makeup artists love from the retailer. Scroll through and take your pick.

Best Overall: Lancôme Lash Idole Mascara ($30)