The Best Olive Oil Subscriptions (2025)

I tried both the regular olive oil and the Olio Nuevo, both of which were delicious. I was drawn to the fruity, ultra peppery notes of the Olio Nuevo, which features a blend of Leccino, Frantoio, Pendolino, and Manzanilla olives. This is the kind of stuff you set out at a dinner party with big hunks of fresh, crusty bread for dipping (the ultimate hack for tiding your guests over when dinner’s running behind schedule). The Olive Oil is milder, a great all-arounder better suited for your sautés, salad dressings, or cake batters.

What we’d leave: My only real gripe with Wonder Valley is the price. At $34 or $36 (at the subscription price) for a 375-ml bottle, this is one of the pricier olive oil subscriptions out there. That said, I do think it’s well worth it for the quality you get.

---

Corto

Tester and reviewer: Emily Farris, senior commerce writer

Corto is a California-based olive oil company that’s dedicated to harvesting olives at their peak and preserving their freshness through the entire oil production process. They have a range of product offerings, including 100% extra virgin olive oil, a sauté oil blend, a Calabrian chili olive oil, and a Chef’s Essentials kit featuring Stanislaus Piccolo Datterini baby plum tomatoes.

What subscription options are available? You can purchase the Truly Extra Virgin Olive Oil in a single 500-ml bottle, a twin pack (two 500-ml bottles), or a 3-L Pantry Size FlavorLock Box (it has a spout, like boxed wine!). Everything in Corto's online shop is available for a one-time purchase, or you can subscribe to receive your selection every two, three, or six months. After you set up your subscription, you can log into your Corto account to skip a shipment, adjust the quantity, or cancel anytime. You can also send any item as a one-time gift.

You can also pay a flat fee to subscribe to Club Corto, the brand’s membership. There are two options here: The Classic Collection, which gives you two shipments per year that each include two Truly 500-ml bottles and one 3-L FlavorLock Box, or the Pantry Collection, which is three shipments with one 3-L FlavorLock Box each. Whichever you choose, you’ll also receive a limited-edition 2025 Argumato-Method Olive Oil as well as access to expert-led virtual olive oil tasting experiences and to chef-led cooking classes.

What Emily loved: Corto's Truly Extra Virgin Olive Oil is rich, fresh, and earthy with a nice bite on the back of the tongue, but it lacks the punch-you-in-the-face olive oil brightness some people (my kids included) find off-putting. My oil shipped with a card letting me know it was from a “fresh fall harvest,” and I didn't have to assume which fall because a date stamp on the back of the bottle confirmed the olives were harvested within the last six months. I loved using this in a simple balsamic vinaigrette, and I dipped quite a bit of Italian bread in it too. I'm eager to try it in an olive oil cake next. Because it's relatively affordable and doesn't have an overpowering olive flavor, it's also a good option for an everyday cooking oil. I'd recommend this for any home cook who never wants to worry about having fresh, high-quality olive oil on hand.

What we’d leave: There are no real cons here, unless what you’re looking for is something super punchy.

---

Flamingo Estate

Flamingo Estate is a California-based olive oil company named after founder Richard Christiansen’s home and orchard in the hills of Los Angeles. The brand also makes candles, soaps, moisturizers, and olive oil using ingredients from a network of partner farms.